Antonio's Italian Deli & Market

Discover authentic Italian flavors at Antonio's Italian Deli & Market in Rye, NY. Enjoy fresh sandwiches, mozzarella, friendly service, and a welcoming vibe. Call +1 914-921-2140 today!

Welcome to Antonio's Italian Deli & Market

Experience the finest dining

Antonio's Italian Deli & Market
Antonio's Italian Deli & Market
Antonio's Italian Deli & Market
Antonio's Italian Deli & Market

Located in the heart of Rye, Antonio's Italian Deli & Market offers a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for enjoying delicious Italian cuisine. From fresh mozzarella to handcrafted sandwiches, every dish carries a taste of Italy. Visitors often rave about the friendly staff who greet you like family, enhancing the overall dining experience. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner, Antonio's has something for everyone.

The extensive menu features everything, from authentic pasta dishes to delectable desserts that leave you craving for more. Stop by for lunch or dinner, and let the vibrant ambiance take you on an Italian culinary journey.

Antonio's Italian Deli & Market shines with its commitment to fresh ingredients and authentic flavors. The menu boasts over 200 items, ensuring every taste is catered to, including specialty sandwiches, pasta dishes, and delightful desserts. One highlight is the homemade mozzarella, praised for its creamy texture and rich flavor that many locals can't resist. The deli’s display showcases a carefully curated selection of Italian groceries and specialty items, making it a go-to spot not just for meals but also for cooking enthusiasts looking for quality ingredients.

The market division enhances the overall offering, allowing customers to pick up essential items like high-quality olive oils, spices, and Italian pastries. Antonio's also features cozy seating areas ideal for gatherings, making it a community staple where neighbors catch up over their favorite dishes.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

540 Milton Rd, Rye, NY 10580, United States

Phone

+1 914-921-2140

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Antonio's Italian Deli & Market
Antonio's Italian Deli & Market
Antonio's Italian Deli & Market
Antonio's Italian Deli & Market

Antonio's Italian Deli & Market stands as a true gem in Rye, NY. It embodies the spirit of traditional Italian delicacies while seamlessly integrating the essence of community. Since opening its doors, Antonio's has become a popular choice for residents and visitors alike, serving up classic dishes with a local twist. Each item on the menu is crafted with care, and the recipes honor the time-honored culinary traditions of Italy. Food lovers often rave about the quality and freshness of the ingredients, which are sourced with meticulous attention to detail.

The deli offers a casual atmosphere that invites visitors to savor meals while relaxing with friends or family.

It’s not just a deli; it's a gathering place for locals to delve into Italian culture through food. From Monday through Sunday, the community cycles through their favorite dishes, creating an unspoken bond among the regulars and staff. The bustling pace during peak hours brings life to the establishment, as families and friends enjoy meals together.

As you navigate the menu, indulge in house specialties, like Chicken Francese or the rich, flavorful Baked Ziti Sorrentino. Pizza lovers enjoy the Cup N Char Pizza, a unique take that has garnered rave reviews.

Desserts like Tiramisu and Cannoli showcase the sweet side of Antonio’s, ensuring that every visit feels like a celebration. With options for all tastes and dietary needs, Antonio's embraces inclusivity, inviting everyone to experience the joy of Italian cuisine. The passion for food, family, and community shines in every corner, making it a must-visit destination in Rye.

Antonio's Italian Deli & Market

Antonio's features a charming exterior adorned with inviting signage and warm colors that hint at the delicious offerings within. The outdoor seating area showcases a vibrant vibe, perfect for enjoying a meal during sunny days. Locals often gather outside with cups of coffee or sandwiches, creating a lively buzz that enhances the community spirit.

The ambiance is family-friendly, fostering a sense of belonging where conversations flow as freely as the espresso. Antonio's radiates a welcome warmth, making it the perfect backdrop for both casual visits and special occasions.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday7 AM-12 PM
  • Monday7 AM-7 PM
  • Tuesday7 AM-7 PM
  • Wednesday7 AM-7 PM
  • Thursday7 AM-7 PM
  • Friday7 AM-7 PM
  • Saturday7 AM-7 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

A great new addition locally here in Rye. I stopped in for lunch today before work. Grabbed The Milton ( prosciutto, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, balsamic on a hero), large cookie, coffee, and a bottle of water. Very reasonable pricing and such great quality, fresh, imported, and delicious. There's indoor seating and room for a few tables out front when they choose to do so. I'll be back; often. A taste of Arthur Avenue for sure, locally.

W
William M.

Since moving to Rye from New Jersey, I've been searching for an authentic Italian spot--and Antonio's Deli is hands-down the best I've found. It's run by an incredibly welcoming, hardworking family who genuinely care about the quality of their food and making every customer feel at home. I've worked my way through the menu (multiple times!), and their sandwiches are unbeatable--seriously, I challenge anyone to find a better chicken cutlet anywhere. Everything is made with fresh, top-notch ingredients. I recently ordered from their catering menu for a party, and it was a huge hit: every dish was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. Antonio's is a true neighborhood gem and a fantastic addition to Rye

W
Will N.

After many years of various food establishments occupying this small space on Milton Ave., I confidently say that Antonio's is here to stay in Rye. The food is consistently outstanding, whether it's breakfast, lunch, or dinner, always fresh with every visit. You can't go wrong with any dish. The owners and staff are exceptionally friendly. In an era when customer service often falls short, these folks set the gold standard. Their pride in serving and ensuring every dish is delicious shows, encouraging repeat visits. Definitely worth a visit--enjoy!

T
TD

Great freshly made mozzarella cheese. Only a handful of places I trust to buy fresh mozzarella.

G
George K.

This place is top notch. Much needed deli in Rye. I went 3 days in a row, get the vecchio sandwich! Owner is awesome as well.

D
Dillon F.

Great new addition to Rye! Joe, Marco and Laura are so warm and welcoming to everyone who enters their place. Killer fresh sandwiches!

w
wanda y.